57 Highland Avenue, Florida, NY 10921

← Back to search

$459,900

bedrooms

bathrooms

square feet

2,275

Acreage

Open Houses

year built

1865

Full Baths

Half Baths

Find out more

Step into history with this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home built in 1865—the same year President Abraham Lincoln's legacy became legend. Located on a spacious village lot with fruit trees, this unique property blends historic character with modern convenience. The first floor features beamed ceilings, a spacious living room, a cozy sunroom, and a kitchen with an original exposed brick wall, gas fireplace, and Dutch door leading to a private deck. One full bath is located on the main level; the second is upstairs along with three comfortable bedrooms. A hidden room on the first floor provides the perfect private office or creative space. A newly constructed barn with electric offers flexible use as a workshop, studio, or storage. Enjoy classic charm, updated comforts, and a property full of potential—all in a historic setting.

Location
Subdivision	-
County	Orange
Elementary School	Golden Hill Elementary
Middle School	S S Seward Institute
High School	S.S. Seward Institute

Driving directions

Open houses

None scheduled.

Find out more

Tell us who you are, and we will have someone reach out to you.

Name*

Email*

Phone*

Message

I have a house to sell

By proceeding, you consent to receive calls, texts and voicemails at the number you provided (may be recorded and may be autodialed and use pre-recorded and artificial voices), and email, from Kotohomes, Howard Hanna Warwick, and their network of service providers about your inquiry and other home-related matters.

Msg/data rates may apply. This consent applies even if you are on a do not call list and is not a condition of any purchase.

MLS number: 867010

Listing agent: listing agent

Listing broker: Howard Hanna Warwick (845) 986-9898

Last update: Monday, June 2 2025 at 7:08 a.m. EDT

randrealty howardhanna